I am tutoring for the Women’s Health course at QUT. Yesterday, I attended my first lecture for the course, given by Dr. Julie-Anne (Ju) Carroll. I really enjoyed it, as Ju is a very engaging lecturer.
At the end of the lecture, Ju played a YouTube clip about
Somaly Mam, who rescues sex workers in Cambodia (some as young as five or six) and offers them shelter and rehabilitation so they can develop a new life. Somaly Mam herself was sold into sexual slavery when she was twelve years old and managed to escape after a decade of suffering. Her story got me thinking about sex workers, and how the law and society perceive them.
The laws governing sex work are complex and they tend to vary drastically from one country to another, sometimes even from one state to another. In Australia, prostitution is regulated and brothels are legal in some states (Queensland, New South Wales, Victoria and ACT) and illegal in others (Western Australia, Northern Territory, South Australia and Tasmania).
In Australia the focus of law enforcement is overwhelmingly against prostitutes, not the clients, and against women rather than men. (1) In places around the world where sex work is illegal (such as Malaysia) it is common for the sex workers to be prosecuted rather than the clients.(2) To me, it is unfair to just penalize the sex workers, and not the Johns.
This unbalanced prosecution could be related to how society perceives prostitution, where many people are morally outraged about prostitution and look down on sex workers. Sex workers are considered as ‘
bad people’ while the clients are considered to have ‘
done something bad’. Society seems to be able to ‘
accept’ someone who solicits for sex, but are harsh and ‘
unforgiving’ towards the sex workers. There seems to be two sets of morals.
Even when sex work is legitimate, it is difficult to remove the stigma associated with it. For example, in Germany sex workers face difficulties with regards to obtaining insurance and in The Netherlands, banks are reluctant to allow sex workers to open business accounts.(3) Again, double standards!
I will continue from time to time to pen down my thoughts about issues that arise in the Women’s Health course.
Notes
(1) Hancock, Linda (1991) Legal Regulation of Prostitution : What or Who is Being Controlled?, in Gerull, Sally-Anne and Halstead, Boronia (eds), Sex Industry and Public Policy, Proceedings of a conference held 6-8 May 1991, pp. 165-171, Australian Institute of Criminology, Canberra, A.C.T.
I was only able to obtain information about law enforcement on prostitution from a 1991 conference paper by Linda Hancock. I have not been able to find any more recent information
(2) In Malaysia, the media show programs about police enforcement on prostitution, where the sex workers are arrested and taken to police station, but the clients are not usually taken into custody
(3) Elaine Mossman, International Approaches to Decriminalising or Legalising Prostitution, Crime and Justice Research Centre, Victoria University of Wellington, Oct 2007